Previous winners
2009 finalists
 |  |  |
| Forced Entry by Dale Bruton winner of the playwriting prize and the audience award | Early Retirement by David Fisher | The King Size by Ted Weesner, jr. |
| directed by Todd Kramer | directed by Gordon Truefitt | directed by Melanie Rada |
2008 finalists
 |  |  |
| The Open Tomb by Anthony Wilks | Mrs. Svoboda and the Baobabs by Nolwenn Treguer winner of the playwriting prize | Public Relations by Jeff Kellner winner of the audience award |
| directed by Melanie Rada | directed by Julek Neumann | directed by Brian Caspe |
2007 finalists
 |  |  |
| Stewie the Stoic by Taso Dirlis | Burn Your Bookes by Richard Byrne winner of the playwriting prize | Old Faithful by Ian Grody winner of the audience award |
| directed by Tyler Gooden | directed by Julek Neumann | directed by Dan Brown |
